Supreme Court: officer’s reasonable mistake of law doesn’t destroy probable cause

When building a criminal defense case, it is always important for defendants to work with an experienced attorney in evaluating the way police investigated the case. This is especially true in cases involving drug charges, which often involve search issues. In some cases, the legal issues surrounding searches can become significant enough that they need to be appealed. It doesn't happen very often that search issues need to be appealed to the highest court in the land, but that is what happened recently.

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled earlier this month in a case involving the question of whether a defendant may exclude from trial incriminating evidence which police obtained after making a mistaken car stop. The case, which is out of North Carolina, involves an individual who was charged with drug trafficking after police stopped on the mistaken belief that it is illegal to drive a vehicle with a faulty brake light. During the stop, officers obtained consent to search the vehicle and found cocaine. Technically, though, driving a vehicle with a faulty brake light isn't against North Carolina law, so officers had no legal basis to make the stop. That, at least, is what was argued. 

The issue arose because of the fact that criminal defendants are often able to exclude from trial evidence which is illegally obtained by police. Officers must have a valid reason to stop a motorist. Usually the reason is that there is some sort of traffic violation. Once the stop is made, officers can gather additional evidence to determine whether there has been a criminal violation.  

In this case, the Supreme Court ultimately came down with a decision that the evidence couldn't be excluded from trial because the officer’s mistake of law was reasonable. In other words, the court ruled that an officer’s reasonable misunderstanding of the law does not vitiate probable cause.

We will continue looking at this issue in our next post, and offer some comments on how an attorney can help in cases where search issues come up.

Source: Fox News, “Supreme Court: Traffic stop, search OK despite misunderstanding of law,” Dec. 16, 2014.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
  • Badge 1
  • Badge 2
  • Badge 3
  • Badge 4
  • Badge 5
  • Badge 6
  • Badge 7
  • Badge 8

Contact O'Brien Hatfield, PA for a free case evaluation today

In Tampa, call (813) 345-4909. In Orlando, call (888) 496-5916 . For fast answers, email us using the form below.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close

Privacy Policy

This site uses Google's Invisible reCAPTCHA, which is subject to Google's Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

Footer Brand

Tampa Bay Office
511 West Bay Street Suite 330
Tampa, FL 33606

Toll Free: 888-496-5916
Phone: 813-345-4909
Tampa Law Office Map

Central Florida Office
121 South Orange Avenue Suite 1500
Orlando, FL 32801

Toll Free: 888-496-5916
Phone: 407-686-1696
Orlando Law Office Map

South Florida Office
Northbridge Tower
515 North Flagler Drive
Suite P-300
West Palm Beach, FL 33401

Toll Free: 888-496-5916
Phone: 407-686-1696
South Florida Office Map

South Florida Office
Brickell Bay Office Tower
1001 Brickell Bay Drive
Suite 2700 M-1
Miami, FL 33131

Toll Free: 888-496-5916
Phone: 305-859-0046
Miami Law Office Map